Many roads combine two types of restraint system: the concrete barrier, which hardly deforms at all, and the steel bridge parapet or safety barrier, which does. The stretch where they meet is one of the most sensitive points of any road restraint layout.

If the connection is made with a simple anchorage, a vehicle striking the steel section can suddenly hit the rigid end of the concrete. The solution is a properly designed and tested transition.

What a concrete barrier is and when it is used

A concrete barrier is a rigid vehicle restraint system: it barely deforms on impact, and its job is to contain and redirect the vehicle. The New Jersey profile is one of the best known.

It is used mainly on motorways and high-capacity roads, central reserves, bridges, viaducts and tunnels, where there is no lateral space for the system to deform. Its advantages are durability and minimal repair after an impact. Its limitation is that it transmits greater impact severity to occupants than a deformable system. We explain this in more detail in types of road safety barriers.

Why the connection with a steel system is a critical point

The two systems respond to an impact in opposite ways. A steel bridge parapet absorbs part of the energy by deforming: its posts and rail move outwards and gradually redirect the vehicle. This displacement is measured by the dynamic deflection and the working width, two parameters that UNE-EN 1317-2 requires to be declared. A concrete barrier, on the other hand, barely gives at all: its deflection is practically zero.

When one system meets the other without a transition, the change in stiffness is abrupt and three risks appear:

  • Pocketing. The steel section deforms just before the concrete and forms a kind of pocket. The vehicle is steered into the end of the rigid barrier instead of sliding along the system.
  • Snagging. If the steel barrier and the concrete profile are not aligned, a wheel or part of the bodywork can catch on the edge of the concrete.
  • Differences in height and geometry. Each system has its own height, profile and position relative to the edge of the carriageway. If they are not matched, the vehicle meets a step instead of a continuous surface.

The result is a hard spot: a stretch that performs worse than either system on its own.

Where this connection occurs

  • At the start and end of bridges and viaducts, where the deck parapet meets the restraint system on the approaches.
  • Central reserves, where concrete barriers sit alongside steel systems at crossover points or on structures.
  • Tunnel portals, where the tunnel wall or rigid barrier meets the restraint system outside.
  • Replacements and upgrades during road maintenance, when a section is replaced and the new system has to connect to the existing one.

How it is solved: the transition

A transition is the section that gradually changes stiffness and geometry between two different restraint systems. It is not just a connecting piece: it must work as a restraint system in its own right.

To achieve this, the transition varies elements such as post spacing and modulation until the behaviour of the steel system matches that of the rigid barrier.

What to check at design stage

  1. Containment level consistent with both systems. The transition has its own containment level, which must be consistent with those of the parapet and the barrier it connects. If it is lower, the connection becomes the weak point of the whole run.
  2. Documented assessment. Technical report CEN/TR 1317-10:2024 provides three routes: full-scale impact testing, numerical simulation validated to UNE-EN 16303, and design rules for similar barriers. Ask the manufacturer for the report supporting the transition and state in the specification which type of assessment is accepted.
  3. Match with the installed system. A transition is assessed with specific systems. If the parapet or barrier installed is not the same as in the assessment, the test result no longer applies to that project.
  4. Geometric compatibility. Check the height of the transition, the kerb and how it fits the profile of the existing or planned concrete barrier. A difference in levels can create the very step the transition is meant to avoid.
  5. Anchorage conditions. The transition is anchored to concrete, so the receiving element must have the dimensions and condition needed to take the anchors. On existing roads, check the condition of the concrete before designing the connection.

What to check on site

A good design can lose its effectiveness during construction. These are the points to watch on site:

  1. Receipt of materials. Before installation, check that the transition delivered is the one specified and that it matches the parapet or barrier installed. A transition from another system, however similar it looks, does not have the assessed performance.
  2. Installation to the manufacturer’s manual. The transition works as a whole: every component, its position and the assembly sequence are part of what was tested. Mixing components from other systems or improvising on site invalidates that result.
  3. Anchor installation. Anchors into the concrete must be installed exactly as defined for the tested system. A poorly installed anchor can fail on impact, right where the two systems meet.
  4. Final geometry. Once installed, check that the height and alignment with the concrete barrier match the design. A mismatch in levels can reopen the step the transition is meant to remove.
  5. Inspection after an impact. In maintenance work, post-accident inspections should also cover the transition, not just the barrier. A damaged transition leaves the connection without its intended protection.

The regulatory framework in brief

Standard UNE-ENV 1317-4 was withdrawn in January 2024, and transitions are now assessed under technical report CEN/TR 1317-10:2024. Transitions do not carry CE marking. In Spain, Orden Circular 35/2014 and Nota Técnica 01/2024 do not specify which assessment method applies in each case; France, by contrast, certifies transitions through the NF058 mark.

For more detail, see the changes in the regulations on barrier transitions and terminals and the assessment of transitions between vehicle restraint systems. You will also find a summary on our vehicle restraint system regulations page.

Metalesa’s transitions to concrete barriers

Metalesa manufactures the META13 transition to concrete barrier and the META16 transition to concrete barrier, which connect the META13 and META16 bridge parapets to the rigid barrier:

  • Containment level: H2.
  • Testing: full-scale impact test to the French standard NF058 at the TRANSPOLIS laboratory (France), meeting part of the requirements of UNE-CEN/TR 1317-10:2024.
  • Certification: NF mark renewed every year through an ASCQUER audit.
  • Installation: anchored to concrete; height 1,235 mm.
  • Protection: hot-dip galvanised to UNE-EN 1461.

The META13 transition to concrete barrier is installed on the A13 motorway, Heudebouville, lot 2, in France. For connections to deformable systems, see all our transitions.

 

Concrete barriers and steel bridge parapets are effective solutions on their own, but the point where they meet is one of the places where the safety of a whole run is decided. An abrupt change in stiffness can make that stretch the weakest on the road.

The answer is to treat the connection as a restraint system in its own right: with an assessed transition that matches the installed systems, is properly defined at design stage and properly installed on site. Planning it from the outset costs less than correcting it later.

With its META13 and META16 transitions to concrete barrier, Metalesa offers a full-scale tested solution for this connection on structures and central reserves.

Do you have a connection between restraint systems in your project? Ask our technical team.